Game Development Community

Organized Resources?

by Infinitum3D · in Site Feedback · 05/19/2009 (2:02 pm) · 7 replies

Just a suggestion...

When I click the RESOURCES link www.garagegames.com/community/resources , a page comes up with resources for T3D, TGEA1.8.1, iTGB v1.2, etc, etc, etc.

Is it possible to have separate pages for the separate engines? Like the TDN homepage?

Thanks!

Tony

#1
05/19/2009 (2:52 pm)
The question is though, who is going to go through all of the resources and determine in which area a specific resource would belong to?

What should be done with resources that can be shared between different engines?

Should they be organized in a way such that some resources would be restricted to owners of a specific engine only? Resources right now aren't restricted in anyway, yet they technically should be.
#2
05/19/2009 (2:59 pm)
Possibly a tagging system would be good enough for sorting and takes care of shared resources, though the first question Michael brings up is still valid in that case...
#3
05/19/2009 (3:19 pm)
I agree that a "tagging" system would be nice.

If resources aren't restricted now, why should they be? If a resource is "tagged" for an engine, then license holders for that engine should have access. The resource probably won't help anyone without those engines anyways.

And most resources modify a small part of the source, they don't contain the entire source.

Again, just a suggestion.

Tony
#4
05/19/2009 (3:47 pm)
"The resource probably won't help anyone without those engines anyways"

I have learned alot from resources i never even use. Having an actual example to show how something is done or can be done is more help then a stack of books.
#5
05/22/2009 (10:32 am)
Yeah, I knew I was in trouble the minute I said that. I must admit, I've read resources from TGB and TGEA and yes, I did find them helpful. Part of the learning experience is finding a way to get a feature from somewhere else to work in your own project.

I still would like to request a "tagging" system, like the Advanced Search has.

Tony
#6
05/22/2009 (11:31 am)
We used to be able to categorize resources and then drill-down through the categories.

It was infinitely more useful than the big ball of mud that we have now.

There's only a thousand or so resources... give me the tool and I'll put in the effort to categorize them.

A few weeks ago I was seriously considering doing this with a simple HTML page that had the categories and linked to the static resource pages with a short write-up about the status and maybe a short note about the resource... kinda like this.
#7
05/22/2009 (11:37 am)
Tagging or categories would be great.